+32 (0) 2 548 04 90 info(at)ecas.org Members Room Contact us
Rights

EU Rights in the Spotlight – January

In December 2016, the European Court of Justice issued two important rulings on child benefits applicable to EU cross-border workers, both concerning Luxembourg.

In the first case, the Court ruled that by making the receipt of a study grant by a child of a frontier worker conditional upon a continuous period of five years of work in its country, Luxembourg had infringed EU law which prohibits unjustified discrimination. Concretely, the Court held that the condition of a continuous period of work of five years, which largely applies to foreign nationals, involves a restriction that goes beyond what is necessary in order to attain the objective pursued by Luxembourg to increase the number of persons holding a higher education degree in the population of Luxembourg.

In the second ruling, the Court held that the stepchild of a frontier worker is entitled to the same social advantages as a biological child would, provided that his stepfather contributes to their maintenance. In other words the Court granted that the parent-child relationship can also be considered from an economic and not only from a legal point of view.

Freedom of Establishment

In December, the EU Court also passed a judgment relevant to the freedom of establishment in a case concerning Greece. The Court ruled that EU law does not in principle prevent a Member State from opposing collective redundancies in certain circumstances, provided it is in the interests of the protection of workers and of employment. However, the legal criteria behind such a decision cannot be vague and imprecise in order to be compatible with the freedom of establishment and the freedom to conduct business in the EU.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This